Unnecessary Friction vs. Intentional Friction: Getting the Balance Right in Financial Services

Jessica Kendall

•

Updated

One of the core principles behind Spinwheel is to eliminate unnecessary friction from financial services. The keyword here is "unnecessary.”

Conventional wisdom in fintech is that friction is always a bad thing. And in many cases, it is. But some friction protects consumers, improves decisions, and builds trust. 

That’s exactly what Alex Johnson, the founder of Fintech Takes, and our CEO Tomas Campos explored recently. And, it is the subject of a new report from Fintech Takes. 

Here are a few key takeaways:

Don’t Treat Friction as an Equal Enemy

For years, financial services has operated on a seemingly straightforward principle. The fewer steps between a customer and a transaction, the better. 

Banks have digitized applications, streamlined payments, automated servicing, and removed obstacles wherever technology made it possible.

That effort has delivered real improvements. Consumers can open accounts from their couches, deposit checks with their phones, and move money in seconds. 

But the industry's success in removing friction has been uneven. Campos gives financial services a solid B+ for eliminating unnecessary friction, but only a C+ for addressing friction associated with fraud, risk, and regulatory controls.

The problem is institutions often treat friction as a universal enemy rather than evaluating the purpose of individual steps. A better approach starts with a basic question: Why are we asking the customer to do this?

If the institution already has the information it needs, another form field accomplishes nothing. If a process requires a customer to repeat information across multiple systems, the problem may be an internal data issue rather than a customer experience issue.

Redesigning the experience around the outcome means rethinking what information institutions actually need, where they can get it, and when they need it. Better access to existing customer data can eliminate repetitive requests while giving institutions the information they need to make better decisions.

The Costs and Benefits of Friction

The cost of unnecessary friction is measurable. According to our consumer research, 65% of U.S. consumers have abandoned a loan or credit card application because it requested too much information. Another 55% have abandoned a purchase because they didn't have their credit card information readily available.

Those abandoned applications and purchases represent lost customers and revenue. But the consequences of friction go beyond conversion. Convenience isn't always synonymous with a better financial experience.

Unlike streaming a movie or ordering dinner, financial transactions can have consequences that are difficult or impossible to reverse. An instant payment to a scammer is still a bad outcome, even if the transaction was technically seamless.

Sometimes, a well-placed interruption is exactly what a customer needs. Alex thinks about friction in two ways:

  • Transactional friction is mechanical. It's the unnecessary work customers encounter because systems don't function as expected. Repeatedly entering information, navigating confusing workflows, or completing steps that serve no clear purpose fall into this category.

  • Relationship friction communicates something about the institution's intentions. It can demonstrate that a provider is looking out for the customer's interests, or reveal that its priorities are misaligned with theirs.

A bank prompting someone to reconsider a risky transaction or offering an opportunity to pay down revolving credit card debt may demonstrate alignment with the customer's financial interests.

An irrelevant cross-sell that interrupts someone trying to complete a transaction does the opposite. Case in point: 43% of consumers say they see offers for credit cards they already have about half the time or more. That's relationship friction of the wrong kind. Instead of demonstrating that the institution understands the customer, it signals that the institution isn't paying attention.

This is where the "unnecessary" part of friction becomes critical. Customers are more willing to accept an interruption when they understand its purpose and see how it benefits them. They're far less tolerant of obstacles caused by disconnected systems, outdated processes, untapped data, or institutional priorities that have little to do with their needs.

Intentional Friction Also Impacts Business Outcomes

There are four common motivations that can lead to intentional friction in a financial services experience:

  1. Customer or lead quality: Gathering additional information to determine whether a customer is a good fit for a product or loan.

  2. Understanding intent: Determining what a customer actually wants to accomplish.

  3. Fraud, risk, compliance, and audit: Maintaining the controls and documentation required to operate safely and meet regulatory obligations.

  4. Customer or margin retention: Creating obstacles that make it harder for customers to leave, refinance, or move their business elsewhere.

The challenge is that these motivations don't always carry equal weight, and they don't always align with the customer's interests.

Lending is a great example of these motivations in action. Some fintech lenders have made acquisition so seamless that they've inadvertently attracted customers or portfolios that don't perform as expected. 

Removing every question from a loan application may improve conversion. But it can also deprive lenders of information that helps them understand borrower intent, assess risk, and make better servicing decisions. Instead of just eliminating as many form fields as possible, lenders should ask whether eliminating that field compromises the quality of the decision.

The opposite problem also exists. Some institutions make it unnecessarily difficult for borrowers to pay off loans with another lender. Think about those lenders that require third-party loan payoffs to arrive by manual check — which adds operational costs like lockboxes, scanning, processing errors, and delays. The underlying motivation might be to discourage refinancing and preserve interest income. But a borrower determined to refinance will find a way to do it. So this is simply making the process more expensive and frustrating for everyone involved.

Institutions need to distinguish between friction that protects the business, friction that protects the customer, and friction that doesn't accomplish either.

AI Agents Change Which Friction Matters

AI agents introduce another complication to the friction conversation. Much of the industry's effort to eliminate friction was built around human limitations. People have limited patience for complicated applications, repetitive data entry, and cumbersome workflows.

AI agents don't have those same limitations.

An agent can navigate an application, gather information, compare products, and complete repetitive tasks without experiencing the frustration that would cause a human customer to abandon the process.

As a result, this changes the game: 

Inertia will no longer be a viable strategy. Institutions will have less ability to rely on customer inertia as a retention strategy. An agent acting on a consumer's behalf won't be deterred by a lengthy cancellation process, inconvenient payoff requirement, or complicated account transfer. Institutions will have to earn loyalty through trust and relationships instead.

Understanding customer intent will move upstream. Lenders will still need to understand why someone wants a loan, but the application may no longer be the right place to ask. As consumers use AI agents to explore their options and determine what they want, more of that understanding may happen earlier in the customer journey. Lenders will need ways to capture and act on those signals before an application begins.

Friction can be a valuable safeguard for AI actions. As AI agents increasingly take action on our behalf, a moment of human confirmation can provide reassurance. Consider an AI agent that is about to make a $500 transfer. Would you welcome a text from your bank asking you to authorize the transaction before it’s completed? Rather than an inconvenience, that interruption creates trust and confidence.

Five Questions to Ask Before Removing Friction

For financial institutions looking to rethink their customer experiences, here are 5 questions to evaluate any step — and potential friction point — in any product:

  1. Intention: What is this step meant to accomplish, and whose interests does it serve?

  2. Necessity: Does the institution actually need to interrupt the customer, or can information it already holds accomplish the same objective?

  3. Execution: If the safeguard is necessary, is there a less cumbersome way to deliver it?

  4. Effectiveness: Does the friction produce the intended outcome?

  5. The AI test: Could an agent handle this step on the customer's behalf? Or does the decision warrant explicit human authorization?

These questions are a good starting point for evaluating everything from loan applications and payment workflows to account servicing and fraud prevention.


Jessica Kendall

Head of Content and Communications

macbook pro on black wooden table

Ready to Build the Future of Consumer Credit?

From acquisition to servicing to repayment, Spinwheel provides the infrastructure behind modern consumer credit. Find out what Spinwheel can do for your business.

macbook pro on black wooden table

Ready to Build the Future of Consumer Credit?

From acquisition to servicing to repayment, Spinwheel provides the infrastructure behind modern consumer credit. Find out what Spinwheel can do for your business.

macbook pro on black wooden table

Ready to Build the Future of Consumer Credit?

From acquisition to servicing to repayment, Spinwheel provides the infrastructure behind modern consumer credit. Find out what Spinwheel can do for your business.